Serve it with fresh berries and crunchy granola for a healthy breakfast or an afternoon pick-me-up, or add it to your favorite recipes that call for vanilla yogurt. Better yet, make my Overnight Oats Recipe with Yogurt for a quick breakfast for busy mornings.
Yogurt is such a perfect complement to so many foods, so trust me when I say the yogurt recipes do not stop here. If you are like me and love the classic combo of yogurt and fruit, you will love this Yogurt Chia Pudding, Frozen Yogurt Bark & my go-to Yogurt Dip for Fruit!

Recipe Ingredients
This quick, easy homemade vanilla yogurt recipe requires only 3 staple ingredients that you probably already have on hand or can quickly grab from the grocery store. You will need plain whole milk yogurt (regular or Greek), vanilla extract, and honey.

Substitutions
The beauty of this easy recipe is that it is totally customizable based on your preferences. Once you make vanilla yogurt from plain yogurt, that is just a jumping-off point! Feel free to substitute or make additions to suit your sweet tooth. Here are some suggestions:
Yogurt: While I personally love that creamy Greek yogurt taste and texture, you can use whatever type of yogurt you prefer for this recipe! Regular yogurt, whole milk yogurt, skim milk, or non-fat yogurt all pair beautifully with vanilla and honey. You can even use plant-based yogurt with maple syrup if you are vegan!
Other sweeteners: To make sweetened Greek yogurt, feel free to adjust the added sugar to your preference. I prefer flavoring plain yogurt with natural sweeteners, like maple syrup and raw honey, but you can use confectioners’ sugar (aka powdered sugar) instead for extra sweetness. You can also use monk fruit sugar or erythritol.
I also recommend being careful when adding artificial sweeteners, like aspartame, sucralose, xylitol, etc., to unsweetened yogurt, as they can strongly affect the flavor.
Vanilla: Adding a dash of pure vanilla extract to plain yogurt is usually what I prefer, but you are also free to use vanilla bean paste as a 1:1 substitute (meaning you can substitute one for equal amounts of the other).
You can also use imitation vanilla extract, which tends to be more affordable. Or, if you prefer, you can use half of a vanilla bean (vanilla beans have a potent flavor, so half of a bean is all you need).
Honey syrup: As another sweetener option for this recipe, you can use my Honey Syrup recipe (a combination of honey and water) for honey vanilla Greek yogurt. If you choose to use honey syrup, use 4 tablespoons of honey syrup in place of the 2 tablespoons of honey.
Ground cinnamon: This is an optional addition, but adding a sprinkle of ground cinnamon to your plain vanilla yogurt really complements the flavors.
How to Turn Plain Yogurt into Vanilla Yogurt
You can whip up this recipe in two minutes. Simply:

Step 1 – Combine the ingredients: Add the yogurt, honey, and vanilla extract to a bowl. Whisk until smooth and well combined.
Why is my vanilla yogurt runny? Regular yogurt makes a looser vanilla yogurt, and Greek yogurt makes a thicker one. If you want it thick, pour off the watery liquid that collects on top before you add the honey and vanilla. That liquid is what makes it loose when you whisk.
Step 2 – Taste and adjust: Give it a taste and add more vanilla extract or honey, if desired.
How to Store
If you have leftovers of this honey and Greek yogurt recipe, you can store them in the fridge or freezer to enjoy later. Here are some tips:
- Storage: You can store your homemade honey vanilla yogurt in an airtight container in the fridge for up to 5 days, or until the date on your yogurt container, whichever comes first.
- Freeze: Freeze your vanilla-flavored yogurt for up to 2 months to preserve the best taste and texture.
- Thaw: To serve vanilla honey Greek yogurt from frozen, thaw your container in the refrigerator first (preferably overnight). The yogurt may appear separated once thawed, which tends to happen when you freeze dairy products. To revive the thawed yogurt, stir it to incorporate the ingredients, or add a small amount of yogurt if it is watery. If it is still not quite smooth, try blending it in a food processor before serving. Make sure not to refreeze once thawed.
How to Use Vanilla Yogurt in Recipes?
Not only can you enjoy this flavorful vanilla Greek yogurt recipe by itself as a breakfast or snack, but you can also use it in any recipe that calls for vanilla yogurt! Here are some vanilla yogurt recipe ideas:
- Make yogurt parfaits: Name a better combo than creamy vanilla yogurt, fresh fruit, and crunchy granola. For one of my favorite vanilla yogurt recipes, try making my Yogurt Parfait recipe!
- Try it in a smoothie: Vanilla yogurt is the perfect addition to any smoothie because it gives it that coveted thick, creamy texture and adds in just the right amount of sweetness. Try adding it to my Strawberry Banana Yogurt Smoothie or Cantaloupe Shake recipe for an ultra-tasty and refreshing smoothie.
- Pair it with fruit: Whether you are making a fruit salad for a brunch crowd, bringing a fruit platter to your next gathering, or setting out a big fruit bowl for dessert, this easy recipe pairs perfectly with all your favorite seasonal fruit.
- Top it off with granola: Something about the crunchy texture and salty-sweet flavor of granola goes so well with yogurt. Simply top a bowl of yogurt with my Chunky Granola and call it breakfast!

FAQs
Yes, you can! Adding a dash of vanilla extract to plain yogurt really complements the tanginess of the yogurt and gives it a subtly sweet taste and flavor. Make it even better by adding 1 to 2 tablespoons of honey!
When making plain yogurt vanilla-flavored, add half a teaspoon of vanilla extract for every cup of plain yogurt. Feel free to add more or less, depending on your personal preference.
If you try your hand at making this recipe, please take a minute to rate it and leave a comment below. It is a great help to others who are thinking of making the recipe. And if you took some pictures, be sure to share them on Instagram using #foolproofeats so I can share them on my stories.
This post may contain affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, I may earn a small commission, at no additional cost to you.

Vanilla Yogurt Recipe
Ingredients
- 1 cup plain whole milk yogurt, regular or Greek yogurt
- 2 tablespoons honey, or maple syrup
- ½ teaspoon vanilla extract
Instructions
- Place yogurt, honey and vanilla extract in a bowl. Whisk until well combined.
- Give it a taste and add more if necessary.
Notes
- Yields: This recipe makes 1 cup of vanilla yogurt, ideal for 2 servings. The information below is for 1 cup.
- Adjust sweetness: I find 2 tablespoons of honey a good place to start, but if you want it less sweet, start with 1 tablespoon and add more after tasting.
- Storage: Store yogurt in an airtight container in the fridge for up to 5 days.
- Freeze: Freeze yogurt for up to 2 months to preserve the best taste and texture.
- Thaw: Thaw frozen yogurt in the refrigerator (preferably overnight). If the yogurt has separated while thawing, stir to reincorporate the ingredients. Add a few more tablespoons of yogurt if it is too watery, or blend for a few seconds in a food processor. Do not refreeze once thawed.
Nutrition
Nutrition information is automatically calculated, so should only be used as an approximation.















Love your dishes where can they be found?
Hello Julie,
Having been a food photographer over 14 years I have been able to collect a lot of plates, bowls, glasses, etc. so it is hard to point one place. However, I do a lot of thrifting and shop from places like Home Goods, TJmaxx, and other similar local places to source my props.
The ones you see on this page are from Anthropology and Home Goods.
I hope this answers your question.
I only had Light Agave on hand, but this was a fantastic recipe. So glad I found it with your overnight oats. My new favorite breakfast. My husband loved it as well.
This is music to my ears Kori. Thanks so much for coming by and taking the time to leave a review.
Hi Aysegul, I love making flavoured yogurts so will definitely give this a go. Out of interest, how many servings does this recipe make? Thanks
This recipe makes ~ 1 cup vanilla yogurt. If you are in my household (we love yogurt), that is 1 serving, but it could be 2 as well. 🙂
Hope this answers your question.
This was a perfect way to make our fruit parfaits more palatable! Thank so much!
I am happy to hear that you liked it. Thanks so much for coming by and taking the time to leave a review.
Perfect way to change plain yogurt into vanilla yogurt!
I am happy to hear that you liked it. Thanks for coming by Lisa.
Why do you specify whole milk yogurt? Wouldn’t this work equally well with low-fat or skim milk yogurt?
Hello Maggie,
I personally enjoy whole milk yogurt, but this recipe would work with low-fat and skim milk yogurt.
I hope this helps.
Great recipe! I had to cut the honey a bit. Closer to 2 tsp instead of 2tbsp because I just prefer not to have it too honey forward, but once I got that happy medium, this was perfect!
I am happy to hear that you enjoyed this recipe Sherre. Thanks for coming by and sharing your experience.
Delicious and easy instructions! My 3 year old and husband loved it with strawberries as a little dessert after dinner.
Hello Morgan,
I am thrilled to hear that you and your family enjoyed this vanilla yogurt recipe. Thanks for coming by and taking the time to leave a review.